Blog

When the Other Side’s Production Is Defective: How to Tell, and What to Ask For

Most defective productions are not hidden. They are just not checked, because nobody is looking at the load file.

A production arrives, it loads, review starts. Three weeks later somebody notices that attachments are not linking to their parents and that a third of the PDFs have no searchable text. By then the deposition schedule is set.

Checking a production takes a few hours at intake and it finds almost everything worth finding.

What to check on arrival

  • Document count against the production log. If the volume says 12,480 and the load file has 12,311, ask before you review.
  • Family integrity. Do attachments resolve to their parents? Broken families are the single most common defect and the easiest to argue about later.
  • Text layer. Spot-check image-only documents for searchable text. A production of scanned images with no OCR is technically compliant with a sloppy protocol and useless to review.
  • Metadata completeness by field. Not whether metadata exists, but whether the agreed fields are populated. Empty date fields across a custodian usually mean a collection problem, not an empty document.
  • Bates continuity. Gaps are not always improper, but unexplained gaps should be explained.
  • Redaction integrity. Can the text under a redaction be selected or searched? It happens more often than anyone admits, and finding it in your opponent’s production is a different conversation than finding it in your own.
  • Modern attachments. If the protocol covers hyperlinked documents, check whether any were actually produced.

What to ask for when something is wrong

Be specific and be early. A letter saying the production is deficient invites a letter saying it is not. A letter saying that 4,112 documents in volume 003 have no extracted text, that the protocol requires extracted text at paragraph 7(c), and that you are requesting reproduction of those documents within fourteen days is a letter that gets a result.

Ask for the reproduction, not for everything. Reproducing a defective subset is a reasonable request that most opponents will meet. Demanding the entire production again over a partial defect turns a technical issue into a dispute.

The same check on your own productions

We QC every production against the production specification before release rather than after a challenge — count, family integrity, text layer, field population, Bates continuity, redaction verification. The cost of catching a defect before a volume ships is an hour. The cost of catching it after is a reproduction, a letter, and a credibility problem.

Pro-Legal Services provides ESI processing, defensible production, load file preparation and production QC for law firms and corporate legal departments across Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia, on Relativity, RelativityOne, Everlaw, DISCO and our own Questa platform. Production QC is built into every matter we process. Where another vendor produced the data, we run the same checks as a fixed-fee production audit — scoped to the volume, priced before we start, and delivered as a defect list you can put straight into a letter.

Related: defensible production, ESI processing, load file preparation, discovery document production, eDiscovery services, Bates labeling, OCR, managed document review.

Pro-Legal Services, Inc. provides production QC and defensible production from Arlington, Virginia, serving law firms and corporate legal departments in Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia, and matters nationwide.

Received a production you are not sure about? Send us the volume count and the production specification and we will quote a fixed-fee production audit before any work starts. On matters we process, these checks are already included. Pro-Legal Services, Inc. · 1550 Wilson Blvd, Suite 250, Arlington, VA 22209 · 202-955-9400 · info@pro-legal.com