Blog

Reading an ESI Protocol Before You Sign It

Most of what an ESI protocol costs is decided by four provisions, and none of them look expensive on the page.

An ESI protocol is a budget document that reads like a technical appendix. By the time anyone discovers what a clause actually costs, it is an order and the argument is over. These are the provisions worth slowing down for.

Deduplication scope

Global or per-custodian. Global deduplication removes a document everywhere it appears and keeps one copy, which is cheaper to host and cheaper to review. Per-custodian deduplication keeps one copy per custodian, which means a company-wide memo sent to forty people is reviewed forty times. On a large population that single word is often the largest number in the matter, and it is frequently agreed without discussion because it appears in a list of definitions rather than in a cost section.

Production format and metadata fields

Native, near-native, TIFF or PDF, and which metadata fields travel with each. A protocol requiring TIFF images with full extracted text and a long metadata field list is more expensive to produce than native with a load file, and for most document types it is less useful to review. Check also whether the field list includes anything your collection does not actually capture — agreeing to produce a field that does not exist in your data creates an obligation you cannot meet.

Redaction conventions

How redactions are applied, whether redacted natives are produced, what happens to the text layer under a redaction, and whether redaction reasons must be logged. Each of those is a labour line. Redacting natives while preserving usability is materially harder than redacting images, and a protocol that requires both is a protocol that doubles a workstream.

Modern attachments and short messages

Whether hyperlinked documents are produced automatically, on request or by agreement, and how instant and text messages are threaded and bounded. A court in the District of Columbia set out a tiered approach in 2026 that is worth proposing as a starting point. Agreeing to produce every linked document as a family member is sometimes technically impossible, and discovering that after the order is signed is an expensive conversation.

The privilege log clause, which is now a rule

Federal Rules 16 and 26 were amended effective 1 December 2025. The discovery plan must address how and when privilege claims will be made, including the format and level of detail of the log, and the court can adopt those terms in the scheduling order and enforce them. A protocol silent on log format is a protocol that will acquire one later, on somebody else’s terms.

Who should read it before you sign

Your vendor, in writing, before the meet and confer rather than after the order. Pro-Legal Services reviews ESI protocols for law firms and corporate legal departments across Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia — not to redline the law, but to tell you which provisions your actual data can support, which ones will produce a motion in four months, and what each one costs.

We have been running ESI processing, managed document review, defensible production and privilege workflows since 1999, on Relativity, RelativityOne and our own Questa platform. The protocols that go badly are rarely the ones with an unusual clause. They are the ones where nobody priced the ordinary ones.

Related: ESI processing, defensible production, eDiscovery services, managed document review, privilege review, hyperlinked document production, discovery document production, legal data management.

Pro-Legal Services, Inc. is an independent litigation support company in Arlington, Virginia, minutes from Washington DC, serving law firms, corporate legal departments and government agencies across DC, Maryland, Virginia and nationwide.

Have a protocol draft on your desk? Send it to us before the meet and confer. We will mark the provisions your data cannot support and tell you what each of the expensive ones actually costs. Pro-Legal Services, Inc. · 1550 Wilson Blvd, Suite 250, Arlington, VA 22209 · 202-955-9400 · info@pro-legal.com