Any participant in a Signal conversation can switch on disappearing messages for everyone in it. Asking custodians what they changed is not a preservation method.
In May 2026 the Delaware Court of Chancery sanctioned a group of custodians over Signal. Two litigation holds had already issued. The custodians did not check their settings, and individual chats were set to auto-delete after hours or less, destroying both existing messages and everything that followed. Federal agents later seized a device; forensic examination recovered chat metadata — creation, participants, changes to retention settings — but no content. The court found at least recklessness and will presume a set of facts true at trial, with the defendants required to rebut them by clear and convincing evidence.
The detail that should change how you run holds is this: retention on Signal is set per conversation, and any participant in a conversation can change it for everybody in it.
Why asking custodians does not work
A custodian can tell you honestly that they changed nothing and still have messages disappearing, because somebody else in the chat turned auto-delete on. A hold acknowledgement form captures intent. It does not capture configuration. The only way to know the state of a custodian’s ephemeral messaging is to look at it.
Pro-Legal Services performs forensic data collection, mobile device forensics, chat data preservation and chain-of-custody documentation for law firms and corporate legal departments across Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia. On matters involving ephemeral messaging we verify retention settings per conversation rather than per custodian, and we document what we found and when.
What survives when content does not
More than people expect. Conversation creation timestamps, participant lists, and changes to retention settings can often be recovered even where message content is gone. That metadata is what turns a gap into a finding — it shows that a chat existed, who was in it, and when somebody changed how long it would live. On the Delaware matter, metadata of exactly that kind was what the court had to work with.
Using ephemeral messaging is not itself misconduct
A federal court in California held in June 2026 that disappearing messages have legitimate privacy and security uses and that their use alone is not evidence of wrongdoing. What moved that court to order a forensic examination was the timing — settings switched on shortly after a preservation order issued. The line is not the tool. It is what happened to it once a duty attached.
That matters for advising clients. Telling a company to stop using Signal entirely is usually impractical and sometimes bad security advice. Telling them to freeze retention settings on identified custodians the moment a hold issues, and to verify rather than assume, is both achievable and defensible.
What to do when a hold issues
- Identify ephemeral platforms in use — Signal, WhatsApp, Teams chat, Slack, and anything a department adopted without telling IT.
- Name them in the hold notice. A notice listing email and documents does not obviously reach a disappearing message.
- Verify retention settings per conversation, forensically, rather than relying on custodian attestation.
- Document the verification with dates, so the record shows what the settings were when the duty attached.
- Remember that group threads have redundant custodians. If one participant preserved, the content may still exist.
The vendors who struggle with this are the ones treating mobile and chat as an add-on to email collection. We have treated them as primary data sources for years, because on most matters now they are.
Related: forensic data collection services, mobile device forensics, chain of custody for digital evidence, litigation hold services, Teams data collection, Slack data collection, chat data preservation, ESI processing.
Pro-Legal Services, Inc. provides forensic data collection and mobile device forensics from Arlington, Virginia, serving law firms, corporate legal departments and government agencies in Washington DC, Maryland, Virginia and nationwide, 24/7/365.
Hold just issued on custodians who use Signal? Call us before you send the notice. Verification has to happen while the settings are still what they were. Pro-Legal Services, Inc. · 1550 Wilson Blvd, Suite 250, Arlington, VA 22209 · 202-955-9400 · info@pro-legal.com